The following Notre Dame football players received consensus honors as All-Americans in the seasons listed:
| Name | Pos. | Year |
| EddieAnderson | E | 1921 |
| Dick Arrington | G | 1965 |
| Ed Beinor | T | 1938 |
| Angelo Bertelli | QB | 1943 |
| Art (Bud) Boeringer | C | 1926 |
| Luther Bradley | DB | 1977 |
| Tim Brown | FL | 1987 |
| Ross Browner | DE | 1976-77 |
| Jeff Burris | CB | 1993 |
| Jack Cannon | G | 1929 |
| Frank Carideo | QB | 1929-30 |
| Dave Casper | TE | 1973 |
| George Connor | T | 1946-47 |
| Bob Crable | LB | 1980-81 |
| Jim Crowley | HB | 1924 |
| Pete Demmerle | SE | 1974 |
| Gerry DiNardo | G | 1974 |
| Larry DiNardo | G | 1970 |
| Gus Dorais | QB | 1913 |
| Bob Dove | E | 1941-42 |
| Al Ecuyer | G | 1957 |
| Nick Eddy | HB | 1966 |
| Clarence Ellis | DB | 1971 |
| Vagas Ferrguson | HB | 1979 |
| Pat Filley | G | 1943 |
| Bill Fischer | G | 1947-48 |
| Tom Gatewood | E | 1970 |
| George Gipp | HB | 1920 |
| Bob Golic | LB | 1978 |
| Jerry Groom | C | 1950 |
| Ralph Guglielmi | QB | 1954 |
| Terry Hanratty | QB | 1968 |
| Leon Hart | E | 1948-49 |
| Paul Hornug | HB | 1955 |
| John Huarte | QB | 1964 |
| Dave Huffman | C | 1978 |
| Art Hunter | T | 1953 |
| Raghib Ismail | F | 1990 |
| Mirko Jurkovic | G | 1991 |
| George Kunz | T | 1968 |
| Joe Kurth | T | 1932 |
| John Lattner | QB | 1952-53 |
| Elmer Layden | FB | 1924 |
| John Lujack | QB | 1946-47 |
| Todd Lyght | CB | 1989-90 |
| Jim Lynch | LB | 1966 |
| Ken MacAfee | TE | 1976-77 |
| Greg Marx | DT | 1972 |
| Mike McCoy | DT | 1969 |
| Creighton Miller | HB | 1943 |
| Wayne Millner | E | 1935 |
| Steve Niehaus | T | 1975 |
| Alan Page | DE | 1966 |
| Walt Patulski | DE | 1971 |
| Nick Rassas | DB | 1965 |
| Tom Regner | G | 1966 |
| Jack Robinson | C | 1934 |
| Frank Rydzewski | C | 1917 |
| Jeff Samardzija | WR | 2005 |
| Tom Schoen | DB | 1967 |
| Marchy Schwartz | HB | 1930-31 |
| John Scully | C | 1980 |
| Emil Sitko | FB | 1948-49 |
| John Smith | G | 1927 |
| Jack Snow | E | 1964 |
| Frank Stams | DE | 1988 |
| Monty Stickles | E | 1959 |
| Michael Stonebreaker | LB | 1988,90 |
| Harry Stuhldreher | QB | 1924 |
| Chuck Sweeney | E | 1937 |
| Aaron Taylor | G/T | 1992-93 |
| Bobby Taylor | CB | 1994 |
| Mike Townsend | DB | 1973 |
| Shane Walton | CB | 2002 |
| Jim White | T | 1943 |
| Bob Williams | QB | 1949 |
| Tommy Yarr, | C | 1931 |
| John Yonakor | E | 1943 |
| Chris Zorich | DT | 1989-90 |
